How Spanish law can better support minors with disabilities
Spanish law recognizes minors’ right to make certain contracts independently, but it lacks clear provisions for those with disabilities who need additional support.
Most teens have phones, tablets, or laptops that give them access to the internet, where they can browse and buy items. They may understand the appeal of buying that new jacket now and paying for it in installments, but do they fully understand that they will also pay interest? What happens if they miss payments or cannot repay the debt?
For some young people with disabilities that affect their understanding or decision-making, assessing these risks can be more difficult. Spanish law recognizes that minors can enter into certain contracts independently, but the legal framework doesn’t clearly establish what additional support they may need to understand the terms and consequences. How can the law protect these young people from financial harm without unnecessarily restricting their independence?
In a paper published in InDret, Núria Ginés Castellet of Esade Law School, Universitat Ramon Llull, examines whether Spanish law provides adequate protection for minors with disabilities that affect their decision-making when it comes to entering into a consequential contract.
Her analysis highlights how some young people could be left without the support and safeguards they need to make informed decisions and avoid potential financial risks.
“I believe we need to seriously consider the possibility of providing minors with disabilities with specific support to exercise their contractual capacity, something the Civil Code does not currently provide for,” says Ginés.
What Spanish law already says
A contract is an agreement between two or more parties that creates obligations, such as paying for goods, repaying a loan, or agreeing to a service.
Just because someone is under 18 doesn’t mean that they can’t enter into a contract. Under Spanish law, Article 1263 of the Civil Code says that minors can enter into contracts permitted by law that are related to everyday goods and services appropriate to their age and social customs. Other contracts may be made with the assistance of their legal representatives, depending on the circumstances.
The law is designed to balance protection with growing independence. Teenagers can benefit from opportunities to make decisions and learn how to manage their affairs. Preventing them from making ordinary transactions simply because they are young would diminish their opportunities to grow into responsible adults.
Spanish lawmakers have also considered the need for disabled people to retain their right to autonomy. Spain’s Law 8/2021 reformed the legal framework by recognizing the importance of individually tailored support. However, under certain circumstances, contracts made by adults with disabilities without required support can be challenged.
Yet the rules that protect adults with disabilities and emancipated minors don’t provide an equivalent formal support framework for non-emancipated minors with disabilities. As Ginés explains, “The mere recourse to parental authority or guardianship, without specifically established additional support, is not enough to provide adequate protection for minors with disabilities in the contractual sphere.”
Two vulnerabilities can overlap
Ginés argues that age and disability can interact to create a heightened vulnerability. A teenager whose disability affects their cognitive or decision-making abilities may understand the basic nature of a transaction but have difficulty assessing its wider consequences.
Consider a purchase paid for in installments. A young person with a disability might understand what they are buying and how much they must pay each month, yet struggle to assess the interest, the consequences of missing payments, or the implications of any guarantees.
Ginés isn’t arguing that a disability automatically prevents someone from understanding a contract's terms and conditions. Indeed, she cautions against making that assumption. Disabilities vary, as do their effects on an individual’s ability to make particular decisions. We must be careful not to deny young people with disabilities the contractual autonomy available to other minors.
Instead, the concern is that general safeguards may be insufficient when a young person needs additional help to understand a commitment, assess its consequences, or protect their interests.
Of course, parents or guardians may provide support, but their ordinary legal responsibilities do not cover every situation. For example, a teenager might want to take out a loan to buy a moped or enter into a housing agreement. If a disability affects their ability to understand the terms or consequences, informal help from a parent may not be enough. They may need a clearer legal framework that establishes what additional support is required and what happens if a contract is made without it.
A tailored approach to support
Ginés argues that “a system of enhanced assistance” should be developed within the framework of parental authority or guardianship, going beyond what these arrangements would normally provide and adapting to the specific needs of the minor with a cognitive or volitional disability. The objective is to provide support proportionate to the individual’s needs, without automatically restricting their ability to make contracts.
Aragón provides a point of reference for possible future reforms to Spain’s general Civil Code. In 2024, the region amended its Civil Law Code (Código del Derecho Foral de Aragón) to address the needs of minors over 14 with disabilities. Those exercising parental authority or guardianship must provide the necessary support within their powers, but can also ask a court to grant them additional powers of representation if the support required exceeds those powers.
This model can’t simply be copied and pasted into Spain’s general Civil Code, because the legal position of minors over 14 in Aragón is different from that of minors under the national framework. Nevertheless, it clearly shows how legislation can recognize that some minors may need more than only standard age-related protections.
The proposal is not to create a blanket system of restrictions, or to presume that a young person with a disability cannot make decisions. It is to establish a clearer route to additional assistance when ordinary arrangements are not enough. Ginés also argues that lawmakers should consider how existing protections against the exploitation of people with disabilities apply to minors.
Protecting autonomy, not restricting it
Ginés argues that the law should account for how age and disability interact to create specific vulnerabilities. Rather than simply combining the protections associated with childhood and disability, safeguards should address the particular circumstances of minors who experience both.
It's about finding a balance. A system that offers too little support may leave some young people exposed to commitments they can’t fully appraise. A system that assumes they can’t make decisions could limit their independence.
Lawmakers should strive to make meaningful autonomy possible: ensuring that young people with disabilities can participate in everyday economic life while receiving the assistance they need for decisions with more serious consequences.
As Ginés suggests, a more specific and proportionate legal framework could help bridge the gap between having the right to make a contract and being adequately supported to exercise that right.
- Compartir en Twitter
- Compartir en Linked in
- Compartir en Facebook
- Compartir en Whatsapp Compartir en Whatsapp
- Compartir en e-Mail
Do you want to receive the Do Better newsletter?
Subscribe to receive our featured content in your inbox.