Environmental dumping: The hidden threat to the European green transition
As Europe maps out ambitious climate goals, it faces a new challenge: carbon-intensive imports from countries with less stringent environmental regulations. Is CBAM the solution?
On a hot day, you grab a fizzy drink can labelled as ‘sustainably produced’. But while the drink itself may be low-carbon, what about the can? If the aluminium was produced in a coal-powered factory in a country with low environmental standards, the can of soda could come with a high carbon footprint.
This scenario is essentially environmental dumping. Carbon-intensive production is outsourced to countries with weaker regulations. The finished goods are sold in regions with stricter climate targets, like the EU.
Companies in the EU often outsource the most carbon-intensive aspects of their product-manufacturing process
How can a product truly be green if its components are not? And how can governments accurately assess the real carbon footprint of a product?
What Is environmental dumping?
Environmental dumping is the practice of relocating the most polluting stages of production to countries with laxer environmental regulations, where polluting is cheaper, and then selling those products at a lower cost in markets with stricter standards. When what is relocated is mainly greenhouse gas emissions, it is also referred to as climate or carbon dumping.
Strictly speaking, it is not dumping as defined in international trade (selling abroad below the price in the home market), but rather a cost advantage that stems from less demanding regulation. For this reason, part of the academic literature questions whether it should be treated as dumping or as a form of implicit subsidy for pollution. Its most studied consequence is carbon leakage: the shift of production and emissions away from regions that put a price on carbon.
Social and environmental dumping: What is the difference?
Both practices compete on costs by taking advantage of regulatory differences between countries, but they cut different costs. Social dumping lowers labor costs, while environmental dumping lowers environmental costs.
They often overlap: value chains that look for lax environmental standards also tend to operate where labor protection is weaker. That is why social and environmental dumping are often described as two sides of the same strategy.
Examples of environmental dumping
The EU has tougher rules on carbon output than some other countries. So, companies in the EU often outsource the most carbon-intensive aspects of their product-manufacturing process, such as smelting aluminium or producing cement, to countries with less stringent carbon regulations. The company may then claim to produce ‘low-carbon’ goods, but in reality, it is only counting the carbon output from its EU-based operations. The least environmentally friendly processes may have taken place in China, India, or other countries.
The most common cases are concentrated in energy-intensive industries:
- Aluminum: smelting consumes large amounts of electricity, so its footprint depends on whether that electricity comes from coal or renewables.
- Steel: production in coal-fired blast furnaces emits far more than production in electric arc furnaces that use scrap.
- Cement: making clinker releases CO₂ both from the energy used and from the chemical reaction itself.
- Fertilizers: ammonia is mostly produced from natural gas or coal.
- Waste: in a broader sense, shipping plastic or electronic waste to countries with weaker controls is also considered a form of this practice. When China closed its doors to waste imports in 2018, part of those flows was diverted to Southeast Asia.
This practice distorts competition, undermines the EU’s efforts to lower carbon output, and conceals the true environmental impact of global value chains (GVCs).
It’s a widespread problem: over half of global industrial emissions between 1988 and 2015 can be traced back to just 25 corporations. And because GVCs are so complex, it’s challenging to determine who is responsible for those emissions, let alone regulate them.
Why is environmental dumping a problem
The EU’s Fit for 55 plan is a commitment to cut emissions by 55% by 2030. But if goods consumed in Europe are made elsewhere with high emissions, the climate benefits are lost, and EU companies are placed at a disadvantage for trying to do the right thing. Emissions are being lowered; they are just being ‘dumped’ on developing countries.
Esade Professor Valentina De Marchi argues that supply chain emissions must be accounted for if we are to meet global climate goals. "Most multinational enterprises no longer carry out the full range of activities involved in producing goods on their own but govern complex networks of suppliers that stretch across borders," she notes, calling for shared responsibility across all stages of production throughout the GVC.
How is europe responding to environmental dumping? CBAM
The EU has long operated its Emissions Trading System (ETS), which effectively allows companies to ‘pay to pollute’ by purchasing emissions allowances. But ETS only applies within the EU. To crack down on carbon dumping, the EU is launching a new tool: the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).
With CBAM in force, the idea of carbon pricing extends to imports. “CBAM is not a trade barrier,” said Vicente Hurtado, Head of Unit for CBAM and Green Taxation at the European Commission, in a recent Esade-Fundación Repsol seminar. “It’s a measure to promote the decarbonization of the production of these goods.”
Starting in 2026, importers pay a carbon price through CBAM certificates
CBAM has the greatest impact on carbon-intensive imports such as steel, aluminum, cement, fertilizers, hydrogen and electricity. Since October 2023, importers have been required to report the carbon content of these products. Since 1 January 2026, in its definitive phase, importers must pay for that carbon through CBAM certificates, whose price is based on EU ETS auctions. Certificates for 2026 imports will be purchased from 1 February 2027 onwards, at the quarterly prices published by the Commission: €75.36 per tonne of CO₂ in the first quarter, €75.28 in the second, and €82.32 in the third.
The impact could be substantial. As Deloitte estimates, importing one tonne of high-emission aluminium could cost EU traders over €1,000 in CBAM fees.
Initial impacts and global effects
CBAM is already influencing global behaviour. Turkey has submitted climate legislation to launch its own ETS and avoid export penalties. China is expanding its carbon market to cover more industrial sectors.
EU traders are adapting their sourcing strategies and seeking out greener suppliers in order to lower their CBAM obligations—and make their supply chains more robust.
Hurtado emphasised that “CBAM doesn’t target countries. What we target is companies,” noting that firms even in high-emission countries can benefit by modernizing their production processes.
Other regions are pursuing different strategies. Many have introduced their own ETS systems, including the UK, Canada and South Korea. The United States has taken a different route: rather than pricing carbon, it is subsidizing decarbonization through legislation such as the Inflation Reduction Act, designed before Trump’s new term. While this has boosted clean energy investment in the US, critics argue that without carbon pricing, it’s unlikely to incentivize low-carbon practices throughout the entire supply chain.
CBAM’s fairness in question
CBAM has been criticized, especially by lower-income countries. Mozambique, for example, could see its GDP drop by 1.5% due to tariffs on aluminum. Poorer countries argue that they are now being punished for emissions they did not cause.
Right now, CBAM includes no requirement to redirect revenues to poorer countries, despite expert calls for using the funds to support low-carbon transitions in developing nations and avert recession-level impacts.
Monitoring and verification remain major challenges
The EU has already approved simplification measures: Regulation (EU) 2025/2083, in force since 20 October 2025, sets an annual threshold of 50 tonnes that exempts small importers, except for hydrogen and electricity. According to the Commission, this exempts 90% of importers while still covering 99% of imported emissions.But, as Hurtado clarified, “we want to treat all products in the same way, regardless of whether they are manufactured in the EU or imported.”
Yet monitoring and verification remain major challenges. Factories in developing countries often don’t have the technology or data to accurately track or report their emissions. According to Deloitte, nearly three-quarters of German companies are struggling to collect the required data from their suppliers. The EU is working on default values and third-party verifiers, but critics warn the system relies heavily on company transparency in a complex global supply chain.
The future of CBAM
CBAM is being phased in gradually. Free allowances for EU companies under the ETS will be reduced between 2026 and 2034, while CBAM obligations increase. By 2034, all affected goods will be fully covered.
In his presentation, Hurtado explained that the Commission is considering expanding the scope of CBAM. It took that step in December 2025: it proposed extending the mechanism to around 180 downstream products with a high steel or aluminum content, such as screws, wire, pipes and metal furniture, and strengthening anti-circumvention rules. The proposal, which the Council and the European Parliament are negotiating in trilogues in autumn 2026 along with further extensions, is set to apply from 1 January 2028.
The EU is also working on anti-circumvention rules to prevent companies from evading CBAM reporting. Further research is ongoing into how to handle exports and reinvest revenues into climate finance.
A global problem demands a global price
Environmental dumping is a global issue that requires an international response. Europe’s answer—CBAM—is not without its flaws. But it should at least serve to decarbonize manufacturing supply chains across borders.
If the countries are serious about reaching net-zero, then every tonne of carbon must be counted—and priced—fairly.
Frequently asked questions
What is environmental dumping?
It is the practice of producing in countries with lax environmental standards, where polluting is cheaper, in order to sell those products at a lower cost in markets with stricter regulation. The emissions don’t disappear: they are shifted to another country and are not counted where the product is consumed.
What are some examples of environmental dumping?
The most frequently cited examples are aluminum smelted with coal-fired electricity, steel from blast furnaces, and cement and fertilizers produced in countries without a carbon price. In a broader sense, it also includes exporting plastic or electronic waste to countries with weaker controls.
What is the difference between social and environmental dumping?
Social dumping cuts labor costs (wages, rights, safety), while environmental dumping cuts environmental costs (emissions, waste). Both take advantage of regulatory differences between countries and often coincide in the same value chains.
What is CBAM and when do payments start?
The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) requires importers to pay for the emissions embedded in certain imports, at a price based on EU ETS auctions and minus any carbon price already paid in the country of origin. It has been in its definitive phase since 1 January 2026. Certificates for that year’s imports are purchased from 1 February 2027 and surrendered with the first annual declaration, by 30 September 2027.
Is environmental dumping illegal?
Not as such. WTO anti-dumping rules refer to selling below normal value, not to differences in environmental regulation. That is why countries turn to their own instruments, such as CBAM, which the EU has designed to be compatible with international trade rules
- Compartir en Twitter
- Compartir en Linked in
- Compartir en Facebook
- Compartir en Whatsapp Compartir en Whatsapp
- Compartir en e-Mail
Do you want to receive the Do Better newsletter?
Subscribe to receive our featured content in your inbox.